Why could my water taste of petrol?
Plastics materials have been one of the major innovations of the 20th century. The humble pipe is one which has benefited from innovation and provided a number of benefits including anti-corrosion properties and flexibility. These have helped enormously with ground movement stresses and soils that aggressively attack some traditional materials such as copper and iron. For underground water pipes, polyethylene (PE) is commonly used as it has good elastic properties and is resistant to corrosion.
The contamination of drinking water quality at the tap by permeation of volatile organic solvents, including petrochemical products or light gases, is well documented. Once a pipe has become contaminated the water becomes unsuitable for drinking and so a “Do not drink” notice is normally issued by the water company. Boiling the water does not help, in fact it can make things worse, as it changes the compounds leached into the water – and in some cases make them harmful.
The science behind is complex and to aid understanding some elements have been simplified to explain the key processes which are taking place. The following describes the transmission processes of a chemical compound into, through and out the far side of a material. In the case of a water pipe this is through the wall and in to the water within it.
Some of the science
In terms of the structure of plastics, if you were able to zoom in and see the individual molecules that make up a plastics material, you would find many of them joined together in chains. These chains are often cross-connected to each other, with the number and strength of these bonds determining the materials characteristics. With fewer weaker bonds holding chains together allows materials like polyethylene to be less crystalline and more flexible which leaves irregular inter molecular spaces. Where the number of bonds is higher and stronger leaving fewer inter molecular spaces, the material would be more crystalline and become stiffer and potentially more brittle.
Diffusion is an important concept to understand why hydrocarbons can permeate into plastic pipes suppling water. All chemical compounds have a measure of chemical potential which will be different in each compound. When compounds come together the chemical potential (often represented as the concentration gradient) are usually unbalanced. This means they will have an urge to distribute themselves equally so that the chemical potential is back in equilibrium.
This movement of molecules from an area of high concentration to an area of low concentration by random motion (see picture below) is called diffusion. You may recall doing an experiment on this when at school. Diffusion will stop once equilibrium is reached, however it does happen in all compound states whether it is a gas, liquid or solid form.
What happens in pipes: as a compound reaches the external wall of a pipe the process of adsorption means that the compound dissolves into the surface of the pipe material. The second stage is the diffusion of the molecules through the pipe material as it tries to equalise, driven by the action of the concentration gradient. The final stage is movement of the compound from the internal pipe surface into the water is by a process known as desorption (the reverse of adsorption). As the compound leaves the pipe, there is a lowering of the balance within the pipe material and diffusion with take place again.
When water is drawn off it affects the concentration levels, which is why it does not always appear consistent. In some cases it can appear as an intermittent problem.
One factor which does affect this process is temperature and this can alter the rate which the processes happens. Generally, as temperature rises, the greater the thermal motion of polymer chains, easing the passage through the polymer.
How can this be prevented?
Prevention is better than cure. Where there is a clear potential for spills, such as petrol station forecourts or where heating oils are stored, precautions need to be taken. Even a small spill can under certain circumstances can travel relatively large distances, so it makes sense that suitable resistant pipes are used as a precautionary measure in case an accidental spill should occur.
In new developments soils should be checked to make sure they have not become contaminated during previous uses. Where soils are contaminated developers will try and avoid these areas provided there is sufficient distance to re-route pipe around them. More often these potential hazards are removed, but where complete removal cannot be guaranteed a suitable pipe solution must be used. The type of contamination dictates which pipe materials may be suitable.
Ducting pipes does not always provide a solution unless the duct material itself can be properly sealed and is resistant to potential contaminating compounds.
What types of pipes are usually used?
For fuel contamination a metallic barrier is usually needed and so either a metal pipe or plastic ‘barrier pipe’ with an inbuilt metal barrier (usually aluminium) can be used. Whilst the aluminium makes the plastic material stiffer it keeps enough flexibility to provide benefits over ridged materials.
Here are few case studies showing these things happen
Case study 1 – relates to a petrol-powered lawnmower. It was hung up in a tool shed which happened to have an earthen floor. Nobody noticed that petrol had started to drip out of the lawnmower and leaked on to the ground where it was soaked up. Unfortunately, there was a blue plastic (MDPE) pipe underneath the shed taking drinking water to the property. The building was a meeting room for a local group and not frequently used. When they came to use it, no body had spotted there had been a problem until they tasted the water, which had a very noticeable taste and odour, indicating something was wrong.
Case study 2 – relates to a service duct. This duct was a purpose made concrete channel, which the home owner had built to make future access easy for the property’s services. They attempted to waterproof it by painting a bitumen like coating on to the inside of the duct. The property’s services were then laid within it including the plastic water pipe. Unfortunately, the plastics pipe was in contact with the coating, which allowed the solvents from the coating to penetrated the plastic pipe. The chemical compounds not only gave the water an unusual flavour but also turned it yellow. It became very clear that something was wrong.
In both of these case studies the only solution was to replace the pipes. As the surroundings were already contaminated a special barrier pipe was needed to ensure there could be no problems in future.
However, it’s not just chemical spills that should be of concern, gas supplies can also be problematical. If there is a leak and the gas comes in to contact with a water pipe it too would migrate through it and affect the water within it. Usually gas pipes are laid closer to the surface than water pipes, to prevent such problems, but this is not always the case.
Top tips – How to avoid potential contamination